like for the first edit you can say, "First Flag Complete" also keep the images to only the heroines and main characters. None of the Mobile characters do not need to in the Badges. Also please NO fan art..
Hmmmm....personally, I feel the names of the badges are all over the place. If they had more...."linear"-ness, such as being related in title, then I would like it, but if the community likes it, what else can I say?
Well, naming isn't much of a problem. The main objective of the system is to make sure the badges are nice-looking. As for names, you and Baharat can easily change it so I'll just try my best to name them.
Well I think it Degrades Haqua, and our wiki to have an image like that for a badge, new comers to our wiki, espically women will look at something like that tell "what a bunch of perverts". You have to understand that we are people who maintain an encyclopedia. And to award someone a fan-service image for doing a good job is like awarding an employee with a stripper for his dedication to his job. Something like this is not right. I dont care if the Anime makers made this but using this in our wiki especially rewarding this to our users for their dedication just does not seem right to me.
In my Opinion, yes, any female in a swimsuit whose personality defines them as "Would never be caught dead in a swimsuit" and then something contridictory happens just because the Perverted fans wanted a "Haqua in a Bikini" picture.
I dont say anything when Kanon is found in a Swimsuit, since Kanon is a character who is supposed to be an idol so seeing her in a swimsuit does not degrade her character.
A Character like haqua who is designed to be in such depth, found in a shallow position in a Bikini, does not help her image.
Let Green or Demise come here and say other wise I will still ask you to change the image.
Some images has to go, yes. I think some do not make sense for their respective badges. I/we could attempt to change the name to fit, but I might need to completely change the whole badge.....I may have mroe to say after Demise, so wait for her opinion...
The level of editor degradation is quite appalling. If I were the one to suggest this, or another admin, responses would range from weak opposition to no comments. If Shiyu does hard work, it should at least be considered before being flat-out rejected.
@ Bharat: It's Haqua. In a Swimsuit. Not a Stripper; You're the one degrading her now. Also, this and this and this are all....not degrading?
mmm...I myself see them as an incentive to spam useless edits on category pages, so I don't use it as a marking stick (how experienced I think an editor is). Special:Editcount is where the real rankings are at ;)
As for Haqua in the swimsuit, I'm fine. All I say is that some are not corresponding to the category. I do consider MaBoss' effort, so I won't ask him to go recust it all, but some atleast need to connect to make some sense, right? All, else, I approve ^.^
I agree that that link is where the real rankings lie...!
Okay, here's the "Music Category" badges(Or as I would prefer, the Kanon-badges). Basically, anyone who edits the "music section" should be able to have lots of them. (Green will totally dominate them XP)
@Demise: I am NOT against the fact that Haqua is in a Swimsuit, or Tsukiyo is Nude in her bathroom. I am against the fact that an editor gets rewarded with an image of Haqua in a swimsuit for making sure every page has a category. The Images should have a relevance with the work they are doing. In essense I would have not had a problem if every image badge had a character in a Bikini. Cause the editor is collecting images.
give me one assosiation between, Categories and provocative images of characters ?
And when I said "Stripper" I believe that you did not read the complete sentence and jumped to conclusions, READ WHAT I SAID "You have to understand that we are people who maintain an encyclopedia. And to award someone a fan-service image for doing a good job is like awarding an employee with a stripper for his dedication to his job. Something like this is not right."
Do you understand what I am saying or do you need me to spoon feed it to you..
Change the image, If you want to Preserve the hard work, use that image for the Images Track
Also about the Music Category track, would it not be better if we had some of the 2B Pencils images as awards too, Instead of the single track of just Kanon ?
Again, what I'm against is the way that you blatantly rejected someone else's work, rather than any subsequent argument you put up. Not only that, you put a stripper in comparison to Haqua in a bikini.
I'm not getting involved in this: I've unfollowed the thread because I'm tired of my message not getting across. Sorry Shiyu, just....be pushed around for this one or something. T~T
Well she is not an interesting character, at one second she is a Psycotic Masochist and at another point she looks like a helpless girl. She is just another Villain with the "Joker" personality and hence she is uninteresting..